The Art of Automation: 5 Tips to Get You Started

Nailing marketing automation isn’t an automated process: it takes a significant amount of up-front strategy and planning. Rachel Schneidmill from The Advisory Board Company, a consulting…

Nailing marketing automation isn’t an automated process: it takes a significant amount of up-front strategy and planning. Rachel Schneidmill from The Advisory Board Company, a consulting firm specializing in health care and higher education, shares with us what she’s learned in their own implementation process.


[dropcap size=small]F[/dropcap]or many companies, marketing automation (MA) has become a strategic tool for demand and lead generation, but some are just getting started. Whether you’re strictly focused on email marketing, or creating a more integrated approach with mobile and social, here are some tips to prepare you for the transition to the ‘automatic’ world.

There is no ‘set it and forget it’

We’ll try not to judge if you’re still sending to the same old static email lists with no regard for user behavior – we’ll let your click rate speak for itself. But even with our prodding to try a different approach, we have to warn you that transitioning to trigger-based emails is not as hands-off as it can sound.

At my company, our digital team is actively marketing 30+ programs at a time. In our old batch-and-blast days, we staggered the email outreach, which was determined by firm priorities. Now, with a marketing automation strategy and software in place, we send almost triple the amount of emails we did three years ago, with user behavior guiding our communication strategy. This may sound like a frequency problem, but truth be told, we carefully select both the audience and the messaging, ensuring recipients are getting emails they truly find valuable. The results are substantially higher click rates and more effective lead generation programs for all products.

Landing Pages, Graphics & Salesforce Campaigns, Oh My!

If the increase in email volume didn’t sound scary enough, it was actually all of the other new assets that put my team in danger mode. We were so excited for our fancy new conversion landing pages, we didn’t think about the fact that they required imagery and actual words. We found ourselves scrambling to put this new process into place with little warning to the design and content teams. (Sorry, guys!)

Take this for what it’s worth: complete a project scope of all new assets needed including parties responsible, and time for execution. This one effort could save you the headache of weeks and months of unfortunate surprises.

There’s More than Just Email

I’ll admit, we’ve been all-email-all-the time at Advisory Board, as that’s been the top warm-lead generator for our sales team for many years. But almost all MA programs now have mobile and social components, content management tools, and a tight integration with paid marketing channels. In short, there are a plethora of options available on top of the out-of-the-box solutions, many of which are worth exploring.

When considering options, spend time understanding how all of these pieces work together. Here are some questions to ask before you dive in to another solution:

• Do the various marketing tools work together seamlessly, like via an API, or does custom work need to be done? Do you have internal resources or expertise to devote to this? If not, there are plenty of marketing automation consultants who specialize in both the platforms and accompanying tools.

• Are these tools actually with external vendors with whom you need a contract – separate from your MA software? What are the extra costs involved?

• What are other clients using, and are there benchmarks you can compare against?

• What information is necessary from your customer relationship management (CRM) software in order for these additional apps to be effective? How difficult will it be to capture its data?

Speaking of CRM

Perhaps the most testing of my patience as a human was when I learned our CRM, Salesforce, and our marketing automation program at the same time, and had to integrate them through endless rounds of live testing. If you have a CRM in place, which I’m sure you do, please make sure you have an IT person (or team) that specializes in your platform to partner with you on integration and long-term maintenance. Because the moment you come up with something cool and neat to try, it will inevitably need their magic touch.

Other MA Users Are Now Your Best Friends

We recently put out an RFP to compare our current automation system with others in the marketplace. The most valuable part of this entire process was the information I received from people I connected with via LinkedIn: one who previously worked for an MA tool, and the other who had worked with two of the competing systems.

Not only did these people provide me with great insights, they pointed me in the direction of specialized consultant agencies that I’m working with now to enhance our marketing reach and effectiveness.

In sum: Prepare a project plan, notify all involved, go beyond email, include IT in everything, and leverage the marketing automation community. And say goodbye to 1% click rates forever.


Rachel Schneidmill Advisory BoardRachel is the director of digital marketing at The Advisory Board Company, a serious food lover, and a health coach. Connect with her on LinkedIn, or follow her on Twitter.

Start generating more leads today!

Contact Us
Sammi Wang headshot

Sammi Wang

Account Manager
sammi@echinachem.com

Sammi is the General Manager China of eChinaChem, where she has worked since 2005 and previously served as Vice President and Sales Manager. eChinaChem offers news media, conferences and events, as well as education and training services in the chemical, pharmaceutical, and healthcare sectors in China. Before eChinaChem, she worked at GlobalSources as an Account Executive. Sammi received her MBA from the University of International Business and Economics and her undergraduate degree from Yantai University.

Sales Territory: China 

Kyra Luttermann Headshot

Kyra Luttermann

Account Manager
kl@intermediapartners.de

Kyra Luttermann is an IT & AI Specialist with a strong academic background, complemented by deep knowledge in Philosophy. She holds advanced training from the University of Oxford in Artificial Intelligence. Kyra excels in AI prompting, consulting, and sales, effectively helping customers reach their target audiences. Since joining IMP and ACS in 2023, she has been instrumental in advancing ACS’s mission, representing the next generation of innovative leaders in the field.

Sales Territories: Germany, Austria, Switzerland, The Netherlands, Ireland, Scandinavia, Belgium, France, Italy, Spain, Portugal, East Central Europe and The Middle East

Uwe Riemeyer Headshot

Uwe Riemeyer

Uwe Riemeyer is a seasoned Global Media Specialist with over 25 years of experience in media sales, consulting, and planning, primarily for the global chemical industry. Since 1997, he has been affiliated with ACS and operates his own successful media business in Germany. Uwe’s expertise spans all B2B industry segments and related media outlets, supported by a solid foundation in economics and an initial career in the automotive industry. His comprehensive knowledge and strategic insights make him a key player in media planning and consulting.

Sales Territories: Germany, Austria, Switzerland, The Netherlands, Ireland, Scandinavia, Belgium, France, Italy, Spain, Portugal, East Central Europe and The Middle East

Jim Beckwith Headshot

Jim Beckwith

Account Manager
j.beckwith@jgeco.com

Jim Beckwith brings his skills to ACS after a lengthy media consulting career in both for-profit and non-profit media. He specializes in helping advertising partners “connect the dots” between their marketing/lead generation objectives and the wide range of opportunities in the ACS Media portfolio. Jim works with advertisers based in the Southeast and Eastern U.S.

Sales Territories: US East Coast and Southeast 

Beth Kurup Headshot

Beth Kurup

Beth Kurup is an Account Manager based in Los Angeles, California. She handles marketing programs for clients in the Western United States. Beth’s media and marketing background aid her in creating strategic plans for clients with a focus on details and meeting objectives.  

Sales Territory: US West Coast Sales

Pete Manfre Headshot

Pete Manfre

Account Manager
p_manfre@acs.org

Except for a brief hiatus in 2022, Pete Manfre has been a fixture at ACS since 2015, helping clients navigate the complex B2B digital landscape. Over the years, Pete has gained the trust of many science marketing leaders with his honest and straightforward approach. His unique insights and expertise have benefitted the small companies looking to gain traction with new potential customers and the well-known industry brands looking to elevate their thought leadership and capture bigger market-share.

Sales Territories: ACS Meetings Exhibition and Sponsorships (ACS Spring, ACS Fall and Pacifichem) 

Chris Nolan

Chris Nolan

Chris Nolan has been creating solutions for C&EN and ACS advertisers since 2017. After growing the western US territory to $1.6M from $800k, he was promoted to national sales manager in 2021. He is based in Chicago and covers the central US and Canada. His background in media solutions includes successful production for such well known global media brands as Fortune, INC, Fast Company, The Nikkei, the FT, and The Globe & Mail.

Sales Territories: US Midwest and Northeast East Coast; Canada; Australia; New Zealand and South America

Mariam Agha 

Account & Marketing Manager
CENBrandLab@acs.org

Mariam is an account manager here at C&EN BrandLab. She works with our clients, art and production teams within C&EN to deliver effective ad campaigns. 

Jordan Nutting Ph.D.

Senior Editor
CENBrandLab@acs.org

Jordan is a Senior Editor at C&EN BrandLab. While earning her Ph.D. in chemistry she also pursued her passion for writing and communication, including a stint as a science reporter during the COVID-19 pandemic. She now funnels her love of words and chemistry into creating compelling science stories and content.

Jesse Harris

Senior Editor
CENBrandLab@acs.org

Jesse Harris is a Senior Editor at C&EN BrandLab. He has been creating internet content since 2016, and has Master’s degrees in both chemistry and chemical engineering. He loves helping STEM experts communicate their science more impactfully.

Shane M Hanlon Ph.D.

Executive Editor
CENBrandLab@acs.org

Shane leads BrandLab’s strategic initiatives and projects. As a conservation biologist turned science communicator and storyteller, Shane brings years of creative and relationship-building experience to BrandLab from his work in the federal government, the National Academies, and scientific membership nonprofits. He is an adjunct professor at the University of Pittsburgh, from which he obtained his B.S. in Ecology and Evolution, and holds a Ph.D. in biology from the University of Memphis.

Heather Lockhart-Neff 

Account & Marketing Manager
CENBrandLab@acs.org

Heather co-leads account management at C&EN BrandLab. She utilizes efficiency and strategy when working with our clients and production teams within C&EN to deliver effective and engaging campaigns. Heather has a passion for telling dynamic stories through multimedia communication channels and brings creativity, curiosity, and charisma to BrandLab partnerships. She obtained her B.S. in International Relations from The College of Wooster in Ohio. 

Cynthia Graham-Tappan 

Managing Director, Sales Strategic Partnerships
CENBrandLab@acs.org

Cynthia Graham-Tappan is an accomplished sales leader with over 15+ years’ experience leading global B2B sales teams within the publishing & media industries.  She has held executive positions with The New York Times, Dow Jones, Agence France Presse, Hearst Corporation and currently oversee Sales & Strategic Partnerships for ACS.   Cynthia has a proven expertise in crafting strategic partnerships, steering high-performing sales teams, and propelling revenue growth. Cynthia also has extensive experience in performance management, market research, digital media monetization, and business development.

Cynthia received her B.S. degree from Towson University and recently completed Executive Education courses with The Yale School of Management and London Business School.  Cynthia resides in Maryland with her husband, and she is a proud mom of four kids.

Kenneth Phan 

Creative Director
CENBrandLab@acs.org

Kenneth is a creative leader with 20 years of experience in in-house and boutique design agencies. He is currently senior creative director for the American Chemical Society’s marketing and communications team. Previously, he was senior creative director for ACS Publications, an international scientific publisher that serves chemistry and related sciences. Kenneth is passionate about translating client business goals into impactful and innovative advertising solutions. Under his leadership, ACS has won numerous awards and accolades for its exceptional design work.